Skip to main content

James Clyde and the Diamonds of Orchestra by Colm McElwain


Mr. McElwain sent this to me to give him my opinion, both as a teacher of young kids and as an avid reader myself who loves fantasy. Here are my thoughts both as a personal reader and as a teacher.

Personal Opinion:
I really liked this series on a personal level as it kept me engaged and was a fun, quick read despite the book being over 200 pages. There were parts that I thought could use a little more development and detail but I also understand that this book was written for middle school kids, not adults. It most areas of the story, I enjoyed seeing what the characters would do and react as children. One of the issues I did have with the book was the fact that James trusted people right away, even without knowing them. It was like he already knew who was good and bad yet how he knew they were good or bad was never explained. Another thing as an adult reader that I would have liked to see is the pace of the story slow down a bit and add more detail and development. The story was pushed from one action to the next with little development or transition. But as I said before, this book was written for kids and not adults and this writing style is good for young readers. Overall though, I really enjoyed the story and would love to read a sequel if it becomes available as the story is perfectly set up for a sequel. Despite being a story for middle schoolers, I thoroughly enjoyed reading it and would love to know what happens next.

Teacher Opinion:
As a teacher, this is definitely a book I would recommend to students as it is fast paced and engaging enough to keep their interest. Chapters are short which make it easy for students to put down the book and pick it back up again easily. There is a lot of action and adventure in the story, which can keep kids interested whereas a lot of extra details or development that adults enjoy would slow down the book and make it more boring to the age group this story is written for. The children in the story are very realistic in most ways which will help young readers relate to them, even though the story is a fantasy. The only parts that I thought were not very realistic was the quick way James took the appropriate action in certain situations where I believe a real kid would falter a bit. Though even then, James does not always make the correct choices and it gets him in trouble quite a bit. At the same time, I recognize that the author used these as a way to drive the plot forward and lead to the next actions. Overall, I would say that middle school kids (and really all ages who are at least at this reading level) could enjoy this story and like me will probably hope to see a sequel come out in the future.

I really enjoyed reading this book and was happy that the author gave me the change to share my opinion on it.
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Duskfire Dragon's Mate by Zoe Chant

I received "Duskfire Dragon's Mate" by Zoe Chant as an Advanced Reading Copy (ARC).  "Duskfire Dragon's Mate" is a shifter romance between a human and a dragon who had a lot of misunderstandings in their past. While trying to avoid too many spoilers, Maya had fled from Corin and the human world to Hideaway Cove, a safe haven for shifters, to protect her son, Tomas, in the previous story, "The Lightning Dragon's Mate."  Maya receives a mystery package that brings Corin back into her life.  Worried about her son, Maya agrees to allow Corin to stay and they begin to discover a world of misunderstandings, not just their own.  It's a sweet story of new beginnings and second chances, as well strengthening of familial bonds with some surprising twists in the plot.  Also, who can resist Tomas' adorable baby dragon antics and stealing of gold?  Though this is the 4th book in Chant's Hideaway Cove series, it can be read as a standalone.  Howe...
Post a Comment
Read more

Forbidden Griffin by Zoe Chant

I received "Forbidden Griffin" by Zoe Chant as an ARC.  "Forbidden Griffin" is a shifter romance between two exiled griffins.  While trying to avoid too many spoilers, Cela is exiled from Griffin Island because her babies were not born griffins.  A nice enforcer suggests she find Tyr to help her out.  Needless to say, Cela and Tyr get a lot more than they bargained for when they meet and Tyr helps Cela get used to living in a human world, as Cela had never been off the island.  They'd make a nice family... if only they could touch.  The story follows Tyr and Cela's journey to break their curse and become a family along the way.  It's a sweet story of new beginnings and second chances, as well as new and blended families.  Though this is the 8th book in Chant's Bodyguard Shifters series, it is easily read as a standalone, though there are a few references to things that happened in prior books.  I will definitely be going back to read the othe...
Post a Comment
Read more

Unholy Murder by Lynda La Plante

  The 7th novel in the Tennison series, "Unholy Murder" by Lynda La Plante starts off slow with the discovery of a coffin in a dig site.  Over the course of the book, many mysteries are unveiled as Jane Tennison tries to get justice for the dead nun.  Relationships are tense, broken and strengthened, as new information is found.  Will justice ever be served or will they perp(s) escape once again?  Though the story is slow to get into, it does become more engaging as it nears the climax and reveals.  There are lots of red herrings and little details that add up to understanding the case.  What is nice about "Unholy Murder" is that you do not need to have read the previous books in the series to enjoy this book.  Any details that you need from the previous books are woven in nicely throughout the natural thread of the story and plot line.  I also liked how detailed the investigation process was as it really gives you insight to what takes place...
Post a Comment
Read more